Article Text

PDF

Rofecoxib caused fewer endoscopic gastroduodenal ulcers than ibuprofen in osteoarthritis
  1. David Henry, MB, ChB,
  2. Patricia McGettigan, MD
  1. University of Newcastle Newcastle, New South Wales, Australia

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    
 
 QUESTION: In patients with osteoarthritis (OA), does rofecoxib at doses of 25 and 50 mg/day cause fewer endoscopic gastroduodenal ulcers than ibuprofen?

    Design

    Randomised (allocation concealed*), blinded (patients, clinicians, and outcome assessors),* placebo controlled trial with 24 week follow up.

    Setting

    33 clinical centres in the United States.

    Patients

    742 patients (mean age 62 y, 68% women, 83% white) ≥50 years of age with OA that had required non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) for ≥6 months. Exclusion criteria were active ulcers; inflammatory bowel disease; previous upper gastrointestinal (GI) surgery; pyloric obstruction; erosive oesophagitis; abnormal serum creatinine levels or clearance; faecal occult blood; unstable medical conditions; history of cancer or cerebrovascular events; bleeding diathesis; or need for anticoagulants, ticlopidine, corticosteroids, or aspirin. The intention to treat analysis included 93% of the patients.

    Intervention

    Patients were allocated to 16 to 24 weeks of rofecoxib, 25 mg/day (n=195); rofecoxib, 50 mg/day (n=186); ibuprofen, 2400 mg/day (n=184); or placebo (n=177). Some other drugs were allowed (acetaminophen, non-NSAIDs, and an antacid [Gelusil]).

    Main outcome measures

    Endoscopic gastroduodenal ulcers ≥3 mm at 12 weeks (primary outcome) and 24 weeks (secondary outcome). A similar analysis was done with ulcers ≥5 mm at 12 and 24 weeks.

    Main results

    Patients in the rofecoxib groups and the placebo group had lower rates of endoscopic ulcers of both sizes than did patients in the ibuprofen group at 12 weeks (table 1); patients in both rofecoxib groups also had lower rates of endoscopic ulcers of both sizes at 24 weeks (p<0.001 for comparisons with ibuprofen). The rofecoxib and placebo groups did not differ for any outcome. Rofecoxib and ibuprofen had similar efficacy.

    Table 1

    Endoscopic gastroduodenal ulcers ≥3 mm with rofecoxib and placebo v ibuprofen for osteoarthritis†

    Conclusion

    Rofecoxib, 25 or 50 mg/day, and placebo had lower rates of endoscopic gastroduodenal ulcers than did ibuprofen in patients with osteoarthritis.

    Commentary

    Most clinicians are aware of the discovery of 2 forms of cyclooxygenase (COX): COX-1, the constitutional form, produces prostaglandins involved in physiological functions; COX-2, an inducible form, produces inflammatory prostaglandins. The distinction between the 2 forms led to a search for drugs that inhibit COX-2, sparing COX-1, in the expectation that such agents would be free of the serious GI toxicity caused by conventional (non-selective) NSAIDs. The first 2 COX inhibitors, celecoxib and rofecoxib, enjoyed successful launches in North America before any publications were available to assess their effectiveness and toxicity. In late 1999, 4 full reports, including these studies by Laine and Simon and their colleagues and 2 others by Langman and Emery,1, 2 were published; accompanying editorials raised doubts about the true value of these agents.3, 4 Overall, the 4 reports describe the experience of >7000 patients with RA or OA treated for 6 to 52 weeks (table 2).

    Accepting that the COX-2 inhibitors are of similar efficacy to non-selective NSAIDs, the main clinical interest is in avoiding clinically important GI damage. During endoscopy, small and superficial ulcers that do not usually cause symptoms are frequently seen in the stomach and duodenum of patients taking conventional NSAIDs. The rates of these mainly non-clinical events with COX-2 inhibitors are approximately 25% of that with conventional NSAIDs. Physicians and patients are, however, more concerned with GI symptoms. Dyspepsia was reduced by only 2% to 3% with a COX-2 inhibitor. Although many patients have been studied in trials of COX-2 inhibitors, few instances of serious GI complications, such as bleeding or perforation, have occurred. The frequency of these potentially serious outcomes is approximately 1% with conventional NSAIDs; COX-2 inhibitors appear to provide a reduction of 0.5% to 1%. This means that 100 to 200 “typical” patients will have to be treated (NNT) with a COX-2 NSAID instead of a conventional NSAID to avoid 1 additional serious complication. In low risk groups, the NNT for serious complications may be around 500.4

    Many patients who are unable to tolerate several conventional NSAIDs will probably be switched to the newer agents, and some will benefit. Although not yet the topic of a published study, patients who are at high risk for serious GI complications (eg, a history of ulcers or GI bleeding) and who need to take an NSAID will probably be the group for whom COX-2 inhibitors will be the most cost effective. Considering the high cost of these new drugs and the widespread use of NSAIDs in most communities, the routine prescription of COX-2 inhibitors cannot be supported.

    Table 2

    Summary of data from randomised trials of gastrointestinal (GI) events with cyclofloxgenase-2 inhibitors v conventional non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) for patients with rheumatoidarthritis or osteoarthritis*

    References

    View Abstract
    • Related BMJ news item

      Merck withdraws arthritis drug worldwide
      Debashis Singh
      BMJ 2004;329:816, doi:10.1136/bmj.329.7470.816-a

      [Read]

      Footnotes

      • Source of funding: Merck & Co., Inc.

      • For correspondence: Dr L Laine, GI Liver Division, Department of Medicine (LAC 12-137), University of Southern California School of Medicine, 2025 Zonal Avenue, Los Angeles, CA 90033, USA. Fax +1 323 226 7573.

      • * See glossary.

      Request permissions

      If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.