Article Text

PDF

Review: calcium supplementation has a small positive effect on bone mineral density but not fractures in postmenopausal women
  1. Steven Cummings, MD, FACP1,
  2. Deborah Sellmeyer, MD2
  1. 1California Pacific Medical Center Research Institute
  2. 2University of California, San Francisco
 San Francisco, California, USA

    Statistics from Altmetric.com

    
 
 Q In postmenopausal women, what is the effect of calcium supplementation on bone mineral density (BMD) and fractures?

    Clinical impact ratings GP/FP/Primary care ★★★★★☆☆ IM/Ambulatory care ★★★★★☆☆ Geriatrics ★★★★★★☆ Rheumatology ★★★★★★☆

    METHODS

    Embedded ImageData sources:

    Cochrane Controlled Trials Register (2001), Medline (January 1966 to April 2001), EMBASE/Excerpta Medica (January 1966 to April 2001), Current Contents (review of the 6 mo prior to April 2001), bibliographies of relevant articles, experts, and proceedings of international meetings.

    Embedded ImageStudy selection and assessment:

    randomised controlled trials (RCTs) that compared calcium supplementation (⩾400 mg/d) with usual calcium intake where both groups received a maintenance dose of vitamin D ⩽400 IU/day and a vitamin D loading dose ⩽300 000 IU; examined women >45 years who were postmenopausal (absence of menses of ⩾6 mo); reported fractures or BMD of the total body, vertebral spine, hip, or forearm; and had follow up for ⩾1 year. 3 independent reviewers assessed methodological quality including allocation concealment, blinding, and losses to follow up.

    Embedded ImageOutcomes:

    BMD and fractures.

    MAIN RESULTS

    15 studies (1806 participants, 953 of whom received calcium supplementation) met the selection criteria. 13 studies reported using allocation concealment. Calcium supplementation did not reduce vertebral fractures but had a small positive effect on all BMD measures except BMD at the lumbar spine at 3–4 years (table).

    Calcium supplementation v placebo on fractures and bone mineral density (BMD) loss in postmenopausal women*

    CONCLUSION

    In postmenopausal women, calcium supplementation has a small positive effect on bone mineral density but does not reduce vertebral fractures.

    Commentary

    The meta analysis by Shea et al shows that calcium supplementation slows bone loss and suggests that calcium supplementation modestly reduces the risk of fractures. These moderate effects and limited evidence, however, may be sufficient to support public health efforts to increase calcium intake because calcium is inexpensive and safe.

    When people think of bone, they reflexively think of calcium and may believe that osteoporosis is largely a deficiency of calcium that can be prevented by increasing calcium intake. Of course, bone strength is controlled by a much more complex array of factors, including other nutritional factors, genetic programming, locally produced cytokines, circulating hormones, and mechanical influences such as weight and exercise. It is reasonable to expect that, by itself, calcium would have a rather modest effect on risk of fracture. It is also reasonable to expect that calcium may play a supporting role for other actors.

    Recommendations on calcium intake should consider the important interplay between this mineral and vitamin D. By itself, vitamin D also reduces the risk of fractures in older adults.1 Trials have shown that the combination of calcium and vitamin D reduces the risk of fractures in elderly patients with osteoporosis2 and those in institutional care.3 A combination of calcium (⩾500 mg/d) and vitamin D supplementation has also been the foundation of treatment in all randomised trials of effective pharmacological treatments, and reasonable doubt exists that potent bisphosphonates or parathyroid hormone would work as safely and effectively in patients who have deficient vitamin D or calcium intake.

    Although the evidence is modest that calcium alone benefits everyone, calcium plus vitamin D (ideally ⩾800 IU/d) remains the cornerstone of prevention of fractures in elderly people and patients with osteoporosis. Evidence about the value of vitamin D and calcium for all postmenopausal women and for prevention of conditions other than fracture will soon be forthcoming from the Women’s Health Initiative.

    References

    View Abstract

    Footnotes

    • For correspondence: Ms B Shea, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. bevsheauottawa.ca

    • Source of funding: not stated.

    Request permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.