Article Text

Download PDFPDF

Using a tape measure for intra-observer variability.
  1. Ian Wacogne, BM, BCh, MRCP, FRCPCH
  1. Birmingham Children’s Hospital, Birmingham, UK

    Statistics from

    Request Permissions

    If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

    This helpful exercise shows inter-observer variability and needs only paper tape measures—1 per member of the group. If you are really short of money, a trip to Ikea can yield a couple. In the group, tell everyone: "Find 3 people in the group to measure your head circumference and tell you the answer. Make a note of each answer; don’t tell anyone any of the results. Don’t give anyone any hints."

    In the context of an adult head circumference of around 55 cm, getting 3 people to be within 1 cm of each other is rare. The narrowest scatter I have observed is 7 mm. If you consider that, in paediatric practice following meningitis, a head circumference that increases by 7 mm in a day will result in urgent head imaging, this is a striking example of how important it is to take into account inter-observer variability when interpreting apparently simple clinical findings.

    The exercise can be extended to show intra-observer variability (or its converse in this context), reproducibility, and the subsequent confidence one can place in one’s own repeated measurements, which improve with repetition. Most experienced measurers will take the average of 3 separate personal assessments, taking the tape away from the head between each measurement. The exercise can be further extended to include an older plastic tape measure to show the unreliability of measuring devices, which alter with time, or with the user "effort" applied, which, if you consider the pliability of a neonatal skull, may be important.

    *Approximately 60 additional journals are reviewed. This list is available on request.
    Acta Obstet Gynecol ScandArch Pediatr Adolesc MedGutJ Vasc Surg
    Age AgeingArch SurgHeartLancet
    Am J CardiolArthritis RheumHypertensionMed Care
    Am J MedBJOGJAMAMed J Aust
    Am J Obstet GynecolBMJJ Am Coll CardiolN Engl J Med
    Am J PsychiatryBr J Gen PractJ Am Coll SurgNeurology
    Am J Public HealthBr J PsychiatryJ Am Geriatr SocObstet Gynecol
    Am J Respir Crit Care MedBr J SurgJ Clin EpidemiolPain
    Ann Emerg MedCMAJJ Fam PractPediatrics
    Ann Intern MedChestJ Gen Intern MedRheumatology
    Ann SurgCirculationJ Infect DisSpine
    Arch Dis ChildCochrane LibraryJ Intern MedStroke
    Arch Gen PsychiatryCrit Care MedJ Neurol Neurosurg PsychiatrySurgery
    Arch Intern MedDiabetes CareJ PediatrThorax
    Arch NeurolGastroenterology

    Journals reviewed for this issue*