Statistics from Altmetric.com
QUESTION: In patients with carbon monoxide poisoning, is hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) more effective than normobaric oxygen for reducing cognitive sequelae?
Emergency departments in Utah, Idaho, and Wyoming, USA.
152 patients (mean age 36 y, 62% men) with documented or obvious exposure to carbon monoxide and any of 11 predetermined symptoms. Patients were excluded if they were <16 years of age, moribund, or pregnant or if >24 hours had elapsed since exposure. Follow up at 6 weeks was 97%.
All patients had 3 hyperbaric chamber sessions at intervals of 6–12 hours starting within 24 hours after carbon monoxide exposure. All non-intubated patients received oxygen, 15 l/min via a non-rebreathing face mask and reservoir. Intubated patients were mechanically ventilated with 100% oxygen. 76 patients were allocated to HBO and exposed to 100% oxygen at 3 atmospheres (304 kPa) and then 2 atmospheres absolute (203 kPa) during the first chamber session and 100% oxygen at 2 atmospheres absolute for sessions 2 and 3. 76 patients were allocated to normobaric oxygen and exposed to air at 1 atmosphere absolute (101.3 kPa, or sea level pressure) for all 3 chamber sessions.
Main outcome measures
Cognitive sequelae at 6 weeks were measured using a battery of neuropsychological tests and were considered present if any subtest score was >2 standard deviations (SDs) below the mean of demographically corrected standardised scores or if ≥2 scores were >1 SD below the mean.
Analysis was by intention to treat. The trial was stopped early after 3 of 4 planned interim analyses were completed. At 6 weeks, 6 months, and 12 months, patients in the HBO group had fewer cognitive sequelae than did patients in the normobaric group (table). The analysis was adjusted for cerebellar dysfunction because it was not equally distributed (4 HBO v 15 normobaric group patients), with no change in results.
In patients with acute carbon monoxide poisoning, 3 hyperbaric oxygen treatments within 24 hours of exposure reduced cognitive sequelae at 6 weeks, 6 months, and 1 year.
Although carbon monoxide, the most frequent cause of poisoning, results in both immediate and delayed cognitive deficits, physicians have been justifiably skeptical about treating it with HBO rather than normobaric oxygen. HBO often incurs the cost and risk associated with transferring a potentially unstable patient to a referral centre, and observational studies that initially suggested a benefit were recently contradicted by a well designed but negative randomised trial by Scheinkestel et al.1
The study by Weaver et al showed a large neuropsychological benefit in the HBO group. This study avoids 2 of the limitations of the study by Scheinkestel et al: loss to follow up and cluster rather than patient level randomisation for group exposures. The Scheinkestel trial also differed in other respects. More patients had attempted suicide (69% compared with 31% in the study by Weaver et al), and depression and other toxins may have influenced outcomes. Patients in the Scheinkestel trial control group received continuous face mask oxygen at 15 l/min for 3 days, whereas patients in the study by Weaver et al received oxygen only when needed to maintain oxygen saturation. Both studies concealed allocation and used sham hyperbaric treatments to enhance blinding, and both used persistent or delayed neurological sequelae as a primary outcome. However, each used a different battery of tests. Similarly, differences in treatment delay, case severity, and HBO protocols might also explain the disparity between the results of these 2 studies.
The study by Weaver et al shifts the balance of evidence to support HBO over normobaric oxygen. Future studies should be designed to determine optimal combinations of the dose and timing of HBO, and planned subgroup analyses should attempt to define which patients could benefit most from hospital transfer. Hopefully, these studies will provide the evidence needed to erase the remaining doubt about the effectiveness of HBO.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.